What is it?
Cherry picking occurs when someone selects only the evidence that supports their position while ignoring or dismissing contradictory evidence. It creates a misleading impression by presenting an incomplete picture of the available information.
Examples
Person A: 'This study supports my position' (while ignoring ten studies that contradict it).
Person B: 'The economy improved in these three metrics during my party's administration' (while ignoring five metrics that worsened).
How to Avoid This
Consider the full body of evidence on a topic, not just what supports your position. Actively seek out contradictory evidence and evaluate it fairly.
How to Counter This
Ask about contradictory evidence: 'You've mentioned the studies that support your view, but how do you account for the studies that found the opposite?'